How to Choose Between a Regular and Roth IRA

by Rick Kahler

How to Choose Between a Regular and Roth IRA photo

Not sure if a regular or Roth IRA would be better for your finances? It’s mostly a question about taxes. Here’s what you need to consider.

When saving money for retirement, taxes are not your friend. Their impact, even for those in lower tax brackets, can significantly reduce one’s retirement income.

One of the better vehicles Congress created to help people save money that can grow tax-free is the Roth IRA. Unlike a traditional IRA, there is no current tax deduction for funds contributed to a Roth, but the funds are not taxed when they are withdrawn.

How do you know when to use a traditional IRA and when to use a Roth? The primary strategy is to pay the tax rate when it is the lowest. For example, if your income tax bracket is higher today than it will be when you need to withdraw earnings in retirement, you want to use a traditional IRA. That results in you avoiding paying any taxes at your high rate today and paying the lower tax rate when you withdraw the funds.

Conversely, if you are in a low tax bracket today and will be in a higher tax bracket when you withdraw the funds, the clear choice is to contribute to a Roth account and pay the lower taxes today because there will be no taxes due at all when you withdraw the money.

You may wonder how this scenario could happen. Doesn’t everyone slip into a lower tax bracket when they no longer have earned income from a job? Not necessarily.

Income in retirement could go up for many reasons: income from multiple pensions, marrying someone in a higher income bracket, receiving an inheritance, or selling appreciated investments. Another scenario is when a job change or cutting back work hours reduces someone’s earnings in pre-retirement years to less than their retirement income will be.

Subscribe to After 50 Finances, our weekly newsletter dedicated to helping you plan for a comfortable retirement even if haven't saved enough. Subscribers get The After 50 Finances Pre-Retirement Checklist for FREE!

Your Email:

You deserve a comfortable retirement.

Subscribe to After 50 Finances, our weekly newsletter dedicated to people 50 years and older. Each week we feature financial topics and other issues important to the 50+ crowd that can help you plan for a comfortable retirement even if you haven't saved enough.

Debt ChecklistSubscribers get The After 50 Finances Pre-Retirement Checklist for FREE!

Your Email:

A trickier question is what to do if you don’t expect to see your tax bracket change. In this case it depends on when you expect to start withdrawing a regular retirement income from your IRA. This scenario favors a Roth if you are very young or if you can reasonably predict you won’t need income from the Roth and can pass on the tax-free withdrawals to your heirs.

The withdrawal requirements on IRAs also can tilt the decision toward a Roth. Unlike traditional IRAs, Roths have no requirement to make annual distributions when you reach age 70 1/2. The one requirement you must meet before withdrawing tax-free from a Roth is that it have been opened for more than five years. A good strategy to consider, according to Michael Kitces, editor of the Kitces Report, is to open a Roth early with a minimal amount like $100, even if you don’t intend to make immediate contributions. This starts the time clock ticking to meet the five-year rule. Kitces notes that the five-year rule only needs to be satisfied once per taxpayer to cover multiple Roth IRAs. He also recommends investing Roth assets in whatever has the highest expected return over time and is the least tax efficient.

Reviewed March 2021

About the Author

Rick Kahler, MSFP, ChFC, CFP, is a fee-only financial planner and author. Find more information at KahlerFinancial.com. Contact him at Rick@KahlerFinancial.com.

You deserve a comfortable retirement.

Subscribe to After 50 Finances, our weekly newsletter dedicated to people 50 years and older. Each issue features financial topics and other issues important to the 50+ crowd that can help you plan for a comfortable retirement even if you haven't saved enough.

Debt ChecklistSubscribers get The After 50 Finances Pre-Retirement Checklist for FREE!

Your Email:

You deserve a comfortable retirement.

Subscribe to After 50 Finances, our weekly newsletter dedicated to people 50 years and older. Each issue features financial topics and other issues important to the 50+ crowd that can help you plan for a comfortable retirement even if you haven't saved enough.

Debt ChecklistSubscribers get The After 50 Finances Pre-Retirement Checklist for FREE!

Your Email:

Will You Be Leaving Thousands In Social Security Benefits Unclaimed By Filing at the Wrong Time?

We recommend a tool from Social Security Choices that can help you determine the best time to collect so you can maximize your benefits.

Click here to maximize your Social Security benefits.

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This